Skip to content
🏆 Free resources for high school sports celebrations — Download the Banquet Checklist

Swag is the line item that quietly eats a banquet budget. A committee orders 150 drawstring bags at $6 each, spends $900, and by July they're in a closet. Meanwhile a $14 hoodie with the team name on it gets worn to school every week until it falls apart. The difference isn't money — it's picking items with a reason to leave the house. Here's how to order swag that gets worn, at prices that survive a booster-club vote.

The Three-Week Test

Before you approve any item, ask one question: would a 16-year-old wear this to school, to practice, or to a friend's house, three weeks after the banquet? If the answer is no, it's not swag — it's a table favor. Table favors are fine (we cover those separately), but they should come out of a different line in the budget and cost $2–4, not $8.

Three things make an item pass the test: it's clothing, it's comfortable, and the design doesn't look like a fundraiser. That last one is where most orders go wrong. A shirt with eleven sponsor logos, the school name, the mascot, the season record, and every player's name looks like a phone book. Nobody wears a phone book.

What Families Actually Wear

  • The hoodie (the undisputed champion). A mid-weight hoodie in a team color, small logo on the chest, "SENIOR" or the sport name on the back. It's the single most-worn item in every team's swag history. Budget $18–26 blank plus printing.
  • The crewneck tee. One-color design, front and center. This is the workhorse — cheap enough to give every athlete, parent, and coach one. Budget $6–9 blank plus printing.
  • The long-sleeve tee. Same design as the short-sleeve, and it gets worn from fall through spring. Often the better buy for fall sports.
  • The beanie or trucker hat. Beanies land reliably with winter sports and with anyone under 25. Trucker hats are hit-or-miss — great for golf and baseball, less so for swimming.
  • Athletic shorts or a cinch bag — only if branded well. Shorts get worn if they're plain with a small logo. Cinch bags get used for about six weeks.

If you can only afford one item, buy the tee. If you can afford two, buy the tee and the hoodie for seniors only.

What Gets Left on the Table

These are the items committees regret most, in rough order of regret:

  • Drawstring bags — every team already has four, and they tear at the grommet within a season.
  • Cheap water bottles — athletes have better ones, and a $3 bottle with a logo leaks.
  • Sunglasses, lanyards, foam fingers, pom-poms, silicone wristbands — fun for ten minutes, in a drawer by Monday.
  • Spirit towels — sounds great, gets used once at a pep rally, then lives in a trunk.
  • Anything with the full roster printed on it — one roster change and the whole order is wrong, and nobody wears a shirt with 22 names on it.

None of these are terrible if they're $2. They're terrible at $7 when the same money buys a shirt people keep for years.

Print Methods, Minimums, and Real Prices

This is where the budget actually gets decided. The same design can cost $6 or $16 depending on how it's printed and how many you order.

  • Screen print — the cheapest per piece at volume, and the only method that makes sense above 48 pieces. Typical shop minimum is 24–48 pieces. Expect $7–11 per shirt at 48–99 pieces and $5–8 at 150+, plus a $20–40 setup fee per color. Lead time: 2–3 weeks standard, 5–7 days rush for a fee.
  • Direct-to-garment (DTG) — no minimum, so it's the answer for a 12-person team or a late add-on order. Costs more per piece: $12–20. Slightly softer, less durable print than screen print, but fine for a season of wear.
  • Heat transfer vinyl — low minimum (often 1–10), $10–16 per piece. Great for names and numbers on the back, or for a small senior class. Won't outlast screen print through 40 washes.
  • Embroidery — usually no minimum, but priced per stitch: $6–12 per logo on top of the garment. This is the right choice for hoodies, polos, hats, and coach gear, where it looks far more expensive than it is.

Blank garment costs to keep in your head: basic tee $3–6, premium/ringspun tee $5–8, long-sleeve $7–10, crewneck sweatshirt $10–16, hoodie $14–22, beanie $5–8.

One hard rule: one color of ink, one location, one garment color. Every extra ink color adds a setup fee and a per-piece charge. A single white print on a dark navy shirt looks better than a four-color design anyway.

The Order Math: How Many of Each Size

Committees under-order large sizes every single year. Athletes are bigger than the general population, and parents will take an XL if it's the last one on the table. Here's a size breakdown that holds up for 100 shirts:

  • S: 6  •  M: 18  •  L: 28  •  XL: 24  •  2XL: 16  •  3XL: 8

Then add 10% overage in L and XL only — that's where the shortages happen. Note that 2XL and up typically cost $2–4 more per shirt, so build that into the quote instead of discovering it at checkout.

Get sizes early: put a required shirt-size field on the RSVP form and use the unisex adult size chart, not youth. If siblings are invited, add a small run of youth M/L — but don't guess, collect it.

Paying For It: Three Models That Work

  • Booster club covers athletes and coaches only. Parents and siblings can buy extras at cost plus $5. This keeps the giveaway number predictable.
  • Online pre-order store. Many print shops host a free team store link for 2–3 weeks. Families order and pay directly, the shop ships one bulk order to the school, and you hit the screen-print minimum without spending a dollar of the budget. This is the single best trick for small teams.
  • Sell the back of the shirt. A single line of sponsor text across the back — "Sponsored by Fenton's Auto Body" — sells for $150–300 and covers most of a 100-shirt order. Keep it to two sponsors maximum so the shirt still looks like a shirt.

The Ordering Timeline

Work backwards from banquet night and put these dates on the committee calendar:

  • 7 weeks out — decide items, quantity, and budget. Get one quote from two shops.
  • 6 weeks out — finalize the design. Keep it to one logo plus one line of text. Get written approval from the athletic director if the school mascot or district logo is involved — many districts require it, and some charge a licensing review.
  • 5 weeks out — place the order and pay the deposit (usually 50%).
  • 3 weeks out — confirm the in-hands date in writing. This is the date that matters, not the ship date.
  • 1 week out — receive, count, and sort by size into labeled boxes. Do not wait until the night before.

Never order custom swag inside two weeks of the banquet unless you're paying rush fees and accepting that the design might ship wrong. It happens more than shops admit.

Handing It Out Without Chaos

The distribution table is where a good order turns into a bad memory. Four rules:

  • Pre-sort by size, not by name. Four boxes labeled S/M/L/XL, plus one for 2XL and up. Two volunteers can hand out 150 shirts in ten minutes.
  • Don't let people choose their own size. Put the boxes behind the table, ask their name, hand them the size from the RSVP list. The moment people self-serve, the XLs vanish in four minutes.
  • Give it at check-in, not at the end of the night. People leave early, and the athletes will put the shirt on immediately — which makes every photo from the night look better.
  • Hold back 10 pieces. Coaches who didn't RSVP, the custodian, the AV kid, the grandparent who drove four hours. You will need them.

Four Mistakes to Avoid

  • Ordering one item for everyone. Coaches and grandparents don't want the same hoodie as the athletes. Buy a small separate run for coaches — embroidered, nicer, and it doubles as the coach gift.
  • Using a design that only works on one color. Ask the shop for a one-color version before you fall in love with a five-color mascot.
  • Forgetting the seniors. A "SENIOR" or "Class of 2027" back print costs almost nothing extra and turns a team shirt into a keepsake. This is the highest-return $1 you'll spend.
  • Not asking about the school's rules. Some districts prohibit clothing with alcohol, tobacco, or gambling references, and a few restrict where sponsor logos can appear. One email to the AD prevents a reprint.

Swag doesn't have to be expensive to be loved — it has to be wearable. Pick one garment people already own too few of, print it in one color, order enough larges, and hand it out at the door. That's the whole playbook.

Pair It With Something They'll Keep: A shirt gets worn, but a custom 3D printed sports centerpiece from Lakeshore Gift sits on a senior's shelf for years — team colors, names or numbers, and personalized per athlete, so each one is a keepsake rather than a giveaway. They also double as table decor, which means one purchase covers two lines of your budget. Browse all sports centerpieces →

Printable Checklist → Next: Keepsake Table Favors →

Related Articles

🎁

Keepsake Table Favors: What Athletes Actually Take Home

Favors that survive the ride home — what athletes keep, what gets left behind, and what to spend per guest.

Read Article →
🏅

Senior Gifts That Teams Can Actually Afford

Real gift ideas with prices, how many to buy, and the ordering timeline that keeps you out of rush fees.

Read Article →
💵

How to Fund a Banquet on a Booster-Club Budget

Where the money comes from, what to spend it on first, and the fundraisers that actually move the needle.

Read Article →